Pocket book #40- What’s a hero?


It will need to have been a wet weekend day the place I didn’t have a lot to do as a result of I made a decision to hire Schindler’s Record and Titanic and watch each motion pictures for the primary time on the identical day, one after one other. That complete expertise was…attention-grabbing.

To be trustworthy, I don’t keep in mind all that a lot about Schindler’s Record now however I very vividly keep in mind the ethical conundrum that I, at the very least, had with the film.

Oskar Schindler was a German industrialist and member of the Nazi Social gathering who employed Jewish and non-Jewish Poles in Krakow, Poland. [For some reason, I thought that he kept these employees as slave labor (with the exception of his Jewish accountant Stern) but Wikipedia indicates he did pay them.]

Extra considerably, he protected his staff from the focus camps, primarily by way of the bribing of Gestapo officers. A lot in order that he went broke paying the Gestapo bribes.

So…finish of the conflict, Schindler is broke, is susceptible to being arrested as a conflict felony and depends on Jewish organizations for sustenance and in an effort to not be arrested as a conflict felony.

And…he’s a hero?

Studying simply now that Schindler did, in reality, pay his staff (versus utilizing his staff as slaves) makes the difficulty of Schindler’s heroism a lot much less complicated. However nonetheless…he was a member of the Nazi Social gathering, endorsing all of these genocidal politics save for his staff who made him cash.

Effectively…to start with, Jewish individuals say that Oskar Schindler is, certainly, a hero, and I defer to their judgment being as they had been the victims of the genocidal Nazis.

If they are saying Oskar Schindler is a hero, then he’s, interval.

The extra important factor that Schindler’s Record made me conscious of was the sheer enormity of the Nazi evil and the downward-spiraling ethical and moral depths that German society gone; a person like Oskar Schindler was, in that social context, a hero, sure.

I’m pondering of this as a result of the ”downward spiraling ethical and moral depths” is what involves thoughts after I take a look at Republican after Republican witness describe what they had been confronted with throughout the time between the 2020 election and the Jan. 6, 2021 revolt and assault on the Capitol. With out that “downward spiraling;” no Republican comes out of those hearings something like a hero and even then…their heroism is debatable.

Extra after the leap.


Right here at Prime Feedback we welcome longtime in addition to model new Day by day Kos readers to hitch us at 10pm Japanese. We try to nourish group by rounding up among the website’s finest, funniest, most mojo’d & most informative commentary, and we rely in your assist!! When you see a remark by one other Kossack that deserves wider recognition, please ship it both to topcomments at gmail or to the Prime Feedback group mailbox by 9:30pm Japanese. Please please please embrace a number of phrases about why you despatched it in in addition to your consumer identify (even in the event you assume we all know it already :-)), so we will credit score you with the discover!

Let’s take former Vice President Mike Pence, as an illustration.

For this train, I need to keep away from any partisan emotions that I could have; clearly I disagree vehemently with Pence’s politics.

Moreover, Article 2 Part 6 of the U.S. Structure stipulates that the first job of the Vice President is to be there when there’s a emptiness within the Workplace of the Presidency; the Vice President can be the President of the Senate and, as such, breaks ties and has a ceremonial function within the counting of the electoral votes.

In all different issues so far as the job description, the Vice President serves on the pleasure of the President so far as duties are involved.

The Vice President, just like the President, additionally swears to an oath…

I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I’ll assist and defend the Structure of america towards all enemies, international and home; that I’ll bear true religion and allegiance to the identical; that I take this obligation freely, with none psychological reservation or goal of evasion; and that I’ll effectively and faithfully discharge the duties of the workplace on which I’m about to enter: So assist me God.

Not like Oskar Schinidler and the Nazi scenario, defending the Structure is the Vice President’s job, towards all enemies, international and home (even when that home enemy occurs to be the President of america, I suppose).

Even in occasions of hazard.

I’ll admit that for Mike Pence, January 6, 2021 was very harmful.

On that day he may have been killed. On that day, he didn’t belief the motive force of his VP motorcade and didn’t comply with his chief of workers and others into that automotive. (Often, you do what Secret Service tells you to do.)

That was a heroic act, sure.

However in filling on this image of the downward ethical spiral that America and the Trump Administration had develop into, we nonetheless aren’t listening to from Mike Pence in individual or perhaps a video-taped deposition.

We don’t know what Trump mentioned to him on that now notorious cellphone name or how the president mentioned it.

Oskar Schindler bribed Nazi officers time after time after time to guard his staff. Schindler went broke defending his staff from the gasoline chambers.

Mike Pence stood as much as Trump’s illegality, however that’s his oath.

He did a brave act and even, dare I say, a heroic act in not moving into that automotive.

However presently, we have to hear what all was mentioned and accomplished from Mike Pence, himself.

Hiding behind your aides, attempting to cover behind the MAGA that received’t elect you…that received’t lower it.

In the end, Mike Pence might be both a…I’ll say it, a hero (nonetheless) or a coward. Price what it might.

It’s his legacy, not mine.

Feedback under the fold.

(Nothing from the sector for Prime Feedback this night)

Subsequent – take pleasure in jotter’s great (and now everlasting) *PictureQuilt™* under. Simply click on on the image and it’ll magically take you to the remark that includes that picture.


June sixteenth, 2022

(NOTE: Any lacking pictures within the Quilt had been eliminated as a result of (a) they had been from an unapproved supply that by some means snuck by way of within the feedback, or (b) it was a picture from the DailyKos Picture Library which did not have permissions set to permit others to make use of it.)

And lastly: yesterday’s Prime Mojomega-mojo to the intrepid mik …… who rescued this characteristic from oblivion:


Supply hyperlink