Cognizant will carry us jobs and prosperity endlessly, amen. Or, possibly not.



1. COVID and faculties

The bright orange rear end of a school bus is photographed looking upward to ward an azure blue sky.

Faculty buses are seen within the car parking zone of a hockey area in Dartmouth on Wednesday, July 22, 2020. — Photograph: Zane Woodford

“The Nova Scotia Division of Schooling confirms an growing variety of youngsters in early elementary college (Major to Grade 4) are struggling to fulfill expectations on the subject of studying,” stories Jennifer Henderson:

This isn’t the fault of scholars or academics or households. It’s nearly to be anticipated contemplating the varsity time youngsters have missed over the previous two years. COVID restrictions and college closures have moved studying on-line to their houses three separate occasions. 

Going again to March 2020, when college disruptions started, the Halifax Examiner requested for details about the studying progress (or lack of it) made by youngsters in early Elementary. 

The division responded by offering report card information from Halifax, the biggest college area with 34,000 college students in Major-Grade 4. Report playing cards use phrases akin to “creating as anticipated” and “wants extra help” to inform college students and fogeys how they’re progressing and if they’re assembly sure benchmarks. 

Over the previous three college years, the Halifax area has seen a 5.5% decline within the variety of college students whose studying is “creating as anticipated” and a corresponding 5.5% improve within the variety of children who “want extra help.” 

There’s additionally a 5% decline within the variety of college students in Grades 1-2 assembly expectations on the subject of writing and a 5% improve in those that want extra assist. 

Click on right here to learn “Early elementary college college students are struggling to fulfill studying benchmarks.”

(Copy hyperlink for this merchandise)

2. Cognizant

Cognizant’s unique company headquarters in Chennai, India, now an offshore supply heart. Photograph: Wikipedia

As I say, a lot of my work is re-writing the identical story again and again. This time round, I’m prompted by the province’s announcement on Tuesday that by giving a gazillion {dollars} in tax breaks to an enormous worldwide agency, there shall be a ton of jobs! jobs! jobs! in Nova Scotia, and we’re all going to be wealthy endlessly, amen:

International expertise providers firm Cognizant has chosen Nova Scotia for its growth plans, serving to to advance the Province’s objectives of attracting new financial alternatives, growing the inhabitants and serving to Nova Scotians entry higher paying jobs.

Cognizant selected us! [insert blushing fiancee emoji here] Take that, some random and not-as-attractive metropolis in Wisconsin!

Over the following seven years, as much as 1,250 new jobs are anticipated from two payroll rebate agreements authorized by the Province for Cognizant, one of many world’s main expertise {and professional} providers firms.

Cognizant will set up a brand new international expertise and repair supply centre in Halifax, the place it’s going to make use of a spread of expertise professionals and enterprise course of outsourcing workers.

Throughout the time period of the agreements, the corporate may spend an estimated $327 million in mixed salaries and advantages – the very best quantity by payroll rebate agreements with one firm in additional than a decade. The Province would gather revenue and consumption taxes from that payroll spending and will return a most rebate of about $27 million to Cognizant. The corporate shall be eligible for a smaller quantity if it creates fewer than 1,250 jobs.

These offers not often meet their targets, therefore the “smaller quantity” of tax breaks written into the settlement.

However even when they do, there are nonetheless two units of objections to them. First, the tax subsidies set up a baseline for calls for for future subsidies, with the corporate endlessly coming again to authorities demanding ever extra concessions, tax breaks, particular offers, and so on. See: Northern Pulp and Michelin.

They usually create a global race to the underside, with numerous jurisdictions vying towards one another to supply ever-lower tax breaks, ever-increasing subsidies. The tip result’s, properly, the world we have now, through which firms dictate to governments how they’ll function, somewhat than the opposite manner round.

The enterprise press is filled with tales of this or that metropolis “shedding out” on a bid to draw Borg, Integrated as a result of the temptations couldn’t measure as much as one other metropolis’s enticements, however has there ever been even one case of a metropolis (or province) rejecting an organization’s proposal as a result of the calls for had been too onerous? Would we even know?

I’m fairly conscious that many individuals studying this proper now can’t even think about “rejecting jobs,” and so we have now the hilarious send-up of the angle in Don’t Look Up: “Your dad and I are for the roles the comet will present” — no price is simply too excessive for jobs.

(Now go re-read my 2013 Coast article “Twenty years of world-class delusion” to see why that is all mistaken.)

However moreover that, what concerning the jobs? Who’s getting them? The deal was couched particularly inside Premier Tim Houston’s purpose of accelerating the inhabitants of Nova Scotia, so will all the roles go to immigrants and college students? In that case, good for them, however what about the remainder of us?

Sure, any financial exercise has secondary results and advantages to contractors, which is why some caterers and AV folks had been agog over the brand new conference centre (how’s that going, eh?), however all this implies nothing if we’re not speaking concerning the distribution of wealth throughout the neighborhood, i.e., inequality.

If the GDP of Nova Scotia goes up by eleventy billion {dollars} as a result of Cognizant involves city, undoubtedly a handful of individuals will profit greater than if the corporate hadn’t. However what concerning the common individual, or these most down on their luck? A rising financial system makes costs general larger, and if plenty of folks aren’t seeing a rise of their pay, we’re worse off collectively, not higher off.

These handful of people that profit from these offers at all times sofa them in constructive phrases — the subsidies are price it, consider the roles! — so subsequently we should lower the tax-collecting capacity of the federal government (that’s what a tax rebate does), such that there’s much less cash accessible for schooling, housing, poor reduction, and the like.

However neglect all that theoretical stuff: let’s discuss concerning the work concerned within the jobs themselves.

Cognizant doesn’t have an incredible popularity. Scratch that: Cognizant has a horrible popularity. Take into account the Wikipedia web page dedicated to the corporate, which has a complete part labelled “Criticism and controversies,” with subheads on Bribery, Corporations Act violations, Discrimination, Layoffs, and Tax evasion. (The small print are far worse than the headlines.)

Cognizant doesn’t say precisely what it is going to be doing in Halifax past creating “a brand new international expertise and repair supply centre.” The corporate has a number of tentacles in a number of totally different providers, however certainly one of them is as a contractor working Fb moderation centres. Reporter Casey Newton wrote about one such centre in The Verge (tw: the article describes a number of very disturbing materials posted to Fb) headlined “The Trauma Ground“:

Collectively, the staff described a office that’s perpetually teetering getting ready to chaos. It’s an setting the place employees cope by telling darkish jokes about committing suicide, then smoke weed throughout breaks to numb their feelings. It’s a spot the place workers could be fired for making just some errors per week — and the place those that stay stay in concern of the previous colleagues who return looking for vengeance.

It’s a spot the place, in stark distinction to the perks lavished on Fb workers, workforce leaders micromanage content material moderators’ each lavatory and prayer break; the place workers, determined for a dopamine rush amid the distress, have been discovered having intercourse inside stairwells and a room reserved for lactating moms; the place folks develop extreme anxiousness whereas nonetheless in coaching, and proceed to wrestle with trauma signs lengthy after they go away; and the place the counseling that Cognizant gives them ends the second they stop — or are merely let go.

A content material moderator named Miguel arrives for the day shift simply earlier than it begins, at 7 a.m. He’s certainly one of about 300 employees who will ultimately filter into the office, which occupies two flooring in a Phoenix workplace park.

Safety personnel preserve watch over the doorway, looking out for disgruntled ex-employees and Fb customers who would possibly confront moderators over eliminated posts. Miguel badges in to the workplace and heads to the lockers. There are barely sufficient lockers to go round, so some workers have taken to retaining objects in them in a single day to make sure they’ll have one the following day.

Miguel is allowed two 15-minute breaks, and one 30-minute lunch. Throughout breaks, he typically finds lengthy strains for the restrooms. Lots of of workers share only one urinal and two stalls within the males’s room, and three stalls within the ladies’s. Cognizant ultimately allowed workers to make use of a restroom on one other flooring, however getting there and again will take Miguel treasured minutes. By the point he has used the restroom and fought the group to his locker, he may need 5 minutes to have a look at his telephone earlier than returning to his desk.

Miguel can be allotted 9 minutes per day of “wellness time,” which he’s supposed to make use of if he feels traumatized and must step away from his desk. A number of moderators advised me that they routinely used their wellness time to go to the restroom when strains had been shorter. However administration ultimately realized what they had been doing, and ordered workers to not use wellness time to alleviate themselves.

Newton stories at size on the psychological results of being a Fb moderator, and possibly that received’t be the perform of Cognizant’s Halifax operation, besides, Newton’s article describes an organization so targeted on income over the well-being of its workers, that it ought to trigger all of us to pause: is that this actually the type of hell we wish to topic our fellow residents to?

(Copy hyperlink for this merchandise)

3. Frequent plan

A brown horse with a white strip on its head is seen on a sunny day. The horse is standing behind a fence, wearing red cheek pieces. In the background, there are two other horses standing in dirt. There are trees further behind.

A horse at Halifax Lancers in 2018. — Photograph: Zane Woodford

“Considerations a few lack of latest public session gave councillors pause, however weren’t sufficient for them to advocate a cease to the Halifax Frequent Grasp Plan,” stories Zane Woodford:

The plan is a proposed redesign of the Halifax Frequent, eradicating some baseball diamonds and including options like bushes, seating, and a trellis. It envisions live shows on the Frequent, utilizing the oval space, and contains the brand new pool authorized final 12 months. Stretching south, there are some landscaping and pathway modifications to the block across the Wanderers Grounds, to the Camp Hill Cemetery, and Victoria Park.

At a digital assembly of council’s Group Planning and Financial Growth Standing Committee on Thursday, councillors debated the plan for the second time. In December, the committee voted to defer a vote due to considerations from the Halifax Junior Bengal Lancers, positioned in what the plan calls the Wanderers Block, between Summer time Avenue and Bell Highway…

The employees report accompanying the plan stated “the Wanderers Block needs to be the topic of a extra detailed plan to contemplate numerous redevelopment alternatives,” and employees stated meaning there shall be additional session on the small print.

Angie Holt, government director and head coach, advised the committee on Thursday the Lancers nonetheless aren’t happy.

“It isn’t the shortage of element that we’re involved with. We perceive additional detailed planning is required,” Holt stated. “It’s the small print as introduced that we have now an issue with as a result of they seem like to the detriment of our group they usually additionally take away any risk for development of Lancers as we have now been discussing with metropolis employees for the previous 4 years.”

Click on right here to learn “Committee recommends adoption of Halifax Frequent plan regardless of requires extra session.”

Concert events on the Frequent, eh? What may presumably go mistaken?

I’m not within the “by no means change a factor concerning the Frequent!” camp, however the obsession with live shows has ruined a number of alternatives.

a man

For this reason we will’t have good issues.

To start with, for no matter cause, it was determined (by Peter Bigelow, by some means) {that a} live performance stage needs to be constructed adjoining to the North Park/Cogswell roundabout. This meant that the Oval was shifted from its initially deliberate web site working parallel to Robie Avenue, over to its present location parallel to Cogswell Avenue, so the ability plant for the ice may double as the ability plant for the live performance stage. Consequently, skaters now face a stiff tail wind coming off Citadel Hill.

I nonetheless check with the large inexperienced bins east of the Oval (between the Oval and the possible live performance stage) as The Harold MacKay Memorial Energy Plant, as a result of why not?

Apart from that, as a result of there’s a imaginative and prescient of 100 thousand folks standing cheek-by-jowl on the Frequent yelling “woo-woo” and pumping their fists as much as Child Rock, an incipient plan to sunlight Freshwater Brook by the Frequent was deep-sixed.

Even at this late date, nevertheless, I nonetheless have a fantasy of the creek being introduced above floor from its Frequent springhead at Griffin’s Pond (now insultingly recreated by the iron-gated fountain), by the Summer time Avenue parking storage monstrosity, to the Public Gardens (the place a few of it pops up even now), down that beautiful swale in Holy Cross Cemetery, skirting Fenwick Tower, throughout the Queen Avenue Sobeys car parking zone, proper down the center of Victoria Highway, then underneath a rebuilt Kissing Bridge on Barrington Avenue, and at last gushing into the harbour, or not less than into the Peninsula Place parking storage.

OK, positive, the Sobeys may need some objection to this plan, however think about not less than a bit stretch of creek working throughout the Frequent, with possibly some shade bushes alongside the financial institution, a little bit of respite from the noise and grit of the town. However no, we will’t even have that due to bureaucrats’ obsession with Child Rock.

By the way, Child Rock is an asshole, nevertheless it was exactly his assholiness that in the end brought about the unlawful live performance mortgage scheme to blow up into scandal:

The paperwork don’t spell out the day-to-day particulars of the negotiations with Child Rock, however it seems that MacKay stored Child Rock on the invoice by dribbling advance cash to him a bit at a time, as he may persuade Anstey to lend extra money.

Ultimately, Child Rock refused to play the sport, and demanded all of the upfront price. On June 23, the redacted individual, greater than seemingly MacKay, wrote to TCL’s controller, cc’ing [Halifax CAO Wayne] Anstey and [Trade Centre Limited president Scott] Ferguson, asking for an extra $600,000 mortgage, however to not pay Child Rock. “That [redacted] will cowl refunds once we cancel (Very Confidentially subsequent week) the Child Rock night time. It’s our plan to supply KR holders to make use of their ticket for BEP which ought to imply lots much less refunds.”

The subsequent day the identical individual writes again, alarmed. “The Company dealing with Child Rock artists has been telling all our different artists’ brokers about their scenario and the demand for additional price funds from our artists is escalating. PLEASE let me know once we may entry funds.”

More and more, my previous reporting serves as historic context for my current reporting. This implies two issues: I’m previous, and I must discover a new schtick.

(Copy hyperlink for this merchandise)

4. COVID and deaths

Eleven Nova Scotians have died from COVID within the final week. That’s not as excessive because the 15/week who had been dying in Northwood in the course of the first wave of the pandemic, nevertheless it’s clearly a horrible lack of lots of people, and almost two years in and with a excessive price of vaccination, such excessive dying charges are dispiriting, to place it mildly.

Worse, whereas I’ve no information of the medical situation of these now in hospital, based mostly solely on the variety of instances and the idea that dying numbers lag case numbers by on common about three weeks, I don’t count on the variety of deaths to lower a lot (if in any respect) over the following three weeks. We’re in for an extended, miserable haul.

I solely say this to arrange you for what seems to be to me just like the inevitable unhealthy information coming.

I’ll have extra to say about all this in at present’s weekly recap, which is able to come out later this afternoon.

(Copy hyperlink for this merchandise)



Committee of the Entire (Friday, 10am) — digital assembly


No conferences

On campus


“’Corruption of the Air:’ Illness and Local weather Change within the Rise of English Caribbean Slavery” (Friday, 3:30pm) — Justin Roberts will discuss through Groups


10th Annual Convention of the Early Trendy (Friday and Saturday) — on-line convention of scholars’ work, with keynote lecture by Roberta Barker; extra information right here

Within the harbour

07:00: Tropic Lissette, container ship,strikes from Pier 42 to Pier 33
08:30: ZIM Shekou, container ship, arrives at Pier 42 from Valencia, Spain
10:30: Tamesis, automotive service, arrives at Pier 31 from Le Havre, France
14:00: Algoma Integrity, bulker, sails from Gold Bond for sea
17:00: Nolhanava, ro-ro cargo, arrives at Fairview Cove from Saint-Pierre
18:00: Asterix, replenishment vessel, sails from Bedford Basin for sea
18:00: Aurviken, oil tanker, arrives at Pier 9 from Level Tupper
20:30: ZIM Shekou sails for New York
21:00: Tamesis strikes to Autoport

Cape Breton
07:45: Aurviken, oil tanker, sails from Level Tupper for Halifax
18:00: Algoma Victory, bulker, arrives at Aulds Cove quarry from Rio Haina, Dominican Republic


It’s a brief Morning File, however consider it or not, a number of work went into it. I’m going for a run earlier than returning to the miserable COVID information.

Converse amongst yourselves.

Subscribe to the Halifax Examiner

We have now many different subscription choices accessible, or drop us a donation. Thanks!


Supply hyperlink