4 cities to check wells after audit raises air pollution issues


4 Minnesota cities will undertake unbiased investigations of their ingesting water provides after a lawsuit by a former state worker and an ensuing audit raised issues about how the state cleans up air pollution from 1000’s of petroleum spills.

The Legislature gave $200,000 to the central Minnesota metropolis of Paynesville, which is able to rent a agency and work with the cities of Alexandria, Blaine and Foley to check the websites of 4 recognized petroleum leaks. The assessments will decide the danger in ingesting the water to raised perceive whether or not the cities ought to dig up and take away the contaminated soil or depart it to interrupt down naturally, because the Minnesota Air pollution Management Company (MPCA) has directed.

“It looks like the best method to do that is to excavate the positioning, clear it up and get all of it out,” Paynesville Mayor Shawn Reinke mentioned. “We excavated a few of it, however we have had fixed pushback over time from the MPCA, saying ‘No, no, no, that is not the best strategy to do it.’ “

MPCA officers mentioned they’ve been testing the standard of ingesting water across the websites of the leaks for years and are assured the water is clear and secure.

“We’ve early warning detection programs in place and we’ll know if the contamination is shifting,” mentioned Jamie Wallerstedt, director of the MPCA’s remediation division. “We’re assured the plume is secure, and we’re going to proceed monitoring it.”

The MPCA’s petroleum remediation program was first known as into query in November, when longtime MPCA worker Mark Toso sued the company, saying managers retaliated in opposition to him for elevating issues that they have been improperly closing instances.

Toso, a leaded gasoline professional who labored within the company’s remediation division from 1992 till he resigned in 2021, mentioned the company routinely categorized leaks that posed a excessive danger to public well being and ingesting water as low danger. The “low-risk” designation allowed the MPCA to shift from cleansing leak websites to shifting ingesting wells away from the contamination and ready for it to naturally biodegrade, which may take greater than a century, Toso argued in his lawsuit.

However whereas the ingesting wells could also be moved to attract clear water, that course of ignores the danger that the contamination nonetheless poses to public, he mentioned — particularly if the positioning is redeveloped sooner or later, or a brand new non-public nicely is drilled, or if the contamination plume shifts and spreads. The MPCA has closed about 5,000 instances of gasoline leaks from storage tanks throughout the state.

Toso’s lawsuit is pending and the 2 sides are scheduled to satisfy for a mediation session in August.

Paynesville’s leak, from underground storage tanks at a former fuel station, occurred within the Eighties. The leaky tanks and among the soil round them have been eliminated, however the contamination unfold and reached two of town’s 4 wells in 1997. Each needed to be closed and changed.

The MPCA dug a collection of monitoring wells to maintain monitor of the contamination. In 2014, benzene — a carcinogen launched from the leaded gasoline leak — was detected about 1,000 toes from the place town is at present drawing its ingesting water. Lawmakers gave Paynesville almost $2 million that 12 months to improve its water therapy plant to take away benzene and related chemical substances. No detections have occurred since, Wallerstedt mentioned.

Toso mentioned in his swimsuit that he and different remediation scientists argued to MPCA managers for years that the Paynesville website wanted to be excavated, in addition to websites with related leaks in Alexandria, Blaine and Foley. Paynesville officers additionally requested for a extra full excavation, and have been pissed off when the MPCA disagreed.

“They advised us any variety of issues for why they weren’t going to excavate, that it was too costly, that it could disturb householders, {that a} faculty is 2 blocks away and you don’t need children coping with the mud,” Reinke mentioned. “It appeared like a brand new excuse relying on the day.”

After studying Toso’s lawsuit, metropolis officers determined they needed unbiased testing.

The Workplace of the Legislative Auditor seemed into the MPCA’s petroleum remediation program following the swimsuit. The audit, launched in February, discovered a number of points and mentioned the company “largely doesn’t contemplate how a property could also be used sooner or later” when deciding if or how you can deal with a petroleum leak.

It additionally discovered that the MPCA depends on consultants — usually employed by the polluters — to analyze the leaks and suggest cleanup actions. Whereas the MPCA evaluations their work and finally decides what actions to take, the standard of the investigations can differ broadly, workers members advised auditors.

The MCPA has no strategy to self-discipline consultants who do a poor job. Consultants should be registered by the state Petrofund Board, an arm of the Division of Commerce, however registration necessities are minimal and do not embody any technical or experience {qualifications}, auditors mentioned.

In response to the audit, MPCA officers mentioned they are going to work to raised incorporate potential future growth into their danger evaluation investigations. They mentioned they have been speaking with the Commerce Division about methods to extend accountability and transparency with the consultants who examine leaks.

However the company has at all times and can at all times be certain that any guide’s work meets the MPCA’s requirements, Wallerstedt mentioned.

“We stand by high quality of our choices,” she mentioned.

Reinke mentioned he is not certain when the brand new testing might be accomplished. He mentioned he hopes it brings residents and metropolis officers peace of thoughts.

“We all know our ingesting water is secure proper now,” he mentioned. “It is frequently examined and unbiased assessments have all come again good. However we wish to be certain that in 20 years, 50 years and 100 years it is nonetheless going to be secure or if we’ll simply be coping with all of this once more.”


Supply hyperlink